In the opening chapters, sixth-grader Ally Nickerson avoids a 'describe yourself' essay by causing distractions and writing only 'Why?' over and over. Unable to read a card, she accidentally gives her teacher a sympathy card. Letters seem to 'squiggle and dance' when she reads. Her brother Travis shows his own cleverness, and a new teacher, Mr. Daniels, arrives — the first adult to look past Ally's behaviour to the bright, creative child underneath.